Breaking EPO News - Decision G 2/19 - oral hearings of the Boards of Appeal can take place in Haar, and third parties cannot appeal clarity of claims during examination procedure.

Breaking EPO News - Decision G 2/19 - oral hearings of the Boards of Appeal can take place in Haar, and third parties cannot appeal clarity of claims during examination procedure.

Breaking EPO News - Decision G 2/19 - oral hearings of the Boards of Appeal can take place in Haar, and third parties cannot appeal clarity of claims during examination procedure.

In one of the fastest ever decisions on a referral, the EPO's Enlarged Board of Appeal yesterday (18 July 2019) found in case G 2/19 that (EPO brief communication; Google translation):

"A third party within the meaning of Article 115 EPC, who has appealed against the decision to grant a European patent, has no right to be heard by a Board of Appeal of the European Patent Office orally over its request to remove allegedly indistinct claims (Article 84 EPC) of the European patent to re-enter the examination procedure. Such a complaint does not have suspensive effect.

Oral hearings of the Boards of Appeal at their location in Haar do not infringe Articles 113 (1) and 116 (1) EPC."

So what does this really mean?

1. Clarity of the claims (Art. 84 EPC) of a European patent application is an issue that can only be decided by the examining division. Third parties cannot intervene to get a decision on clarity from a Board of Appeal.

Clarity is not a formal ground of opposition (Art. 100 EPC)  (although it can be raised during opposition if the patentee seeks to amend the granted claims - the Opposition Division will then determine whether the newly amended claims comply with the requirements of the EPC), and so perceived ambiguity in the scope of protection offered by claims can cause issues for third parties. This decision confirms that:

(a) a third party cannot appeal the decision of an examining division to grant a patent on the basis of clarity, and

(b) such an appeal cannot suspend the grant procedure at the EPO.

2. The decision of the former EPO President to move the Boards of Appeal from their location in Munich to Haar is valid.

The full grounds of the decision have not issued yet, and should be very interesting reading when they do issue.

Jim Robertson, Partner and Patent Attorney 

Related News

EPO Board of Appeal finds Broad Institute’s CRISPR patent to lack valid priority claim and upholds revocation of patent (T 0844/18)
news

EPO Board of Appeal finds Broad Institute’s CRISPR patent to lack valid priority claim and upholds revocation of patent (T 0844/18)

This week’s hearing at the EPO concerning Broad Institute’s CRISPR/Cas9 patent was arguably one of the most high-profile appeals recently...

'Tis the season to beware fake goods
news

'Tis the season to beware fake goods

The last shopping weekend before Christmas is fast approaching and every year unsuspecting buyers end up with fake goods. It's an ever-increasing problem and one that costs the economy more than £1.3 billion in lost profits and taxes. In this article, we answer your most frequently asked questions about counterfeit goods. 

Brexit and the General Election
news

Brexit and the General Election

What will happen with intellectual property after Brexit has been known for some time, but no one has been sure whether these changes would ever actually take effect, or, if so, when.  But now we do.  The votes are cast in the 2019 General Election, and the results are in.  We know that the Conservative Party has won another five years in power, and that, going forward, it can rely on support from a large majority of elected members of Parliament. 

From Examiner to Patent Attorney
news

From Examiner to Patent Attorney

As a Patent Attorney it’s useful to be able to think like an examiner and doing so is easier if you’ve been one. I started my career at the UKIPO in Newport as a Patent Examiner, a role that required looking at both the technical and legal aspects of a patent application and comparing the invention against those found in patent databases to decide whether to grant a patent. After two years I decide to cross to the “other side of the fence” in search of a new adventure. Jumping to the “other side” dispelled many myths revolving around the profession and helped me to understand that Attorneys and Examiners work toward the same goal: Getting good quality patents granted.

Ten big brands -  Welsh Cosmetics and Beauty sector
news

Ten big brands – Welsh Cosmetics and Beauty sector

Establishing a strong brand is pivotal to business success and protecting that brand is equally important. A brand’s intellectual property rights may include copyrights, trademarks, patents, and more.

Wales is a hotbed of great brands. In our regular series – ‘Ten big brands’ – next we take look at some of the best brands in the Welsh Cosmetics and Beauty sector.

Take a look through this selection, and feel free to get in touch with any big brands you think are missing.

Plant Patents at the EPO - are the Boards of Appeal a "bureaucratic obstacle"?
news

Plant Patents at the EPO - are the Boards of Appeal a "bureaucratic obstacle"?

Following on from our previous news articles and the EPO President's referral of the matter to the Enlarged Board of Appeal (EBA; case G 3/19), there has been recent  activity at the European Parliament with one MEP describing the whole issue as a "bureaucratic obstacle".

Ten big brands – Welsh food sector
news

Ten big brands – Welsh food sector

Establishing a strong brand is pivotal to business success and protecting that brand is equally important. A brand’s intellectual property rights may include copyrights, trademarks, patents, and more.

Wales is a hotbed of great brands. In a regular series of blogs, we take look at some of the best brands in the Welsh food sector.

Take a look through this selection, and feel free to get in touch with any big brands you think are missing.

Ten big brands – Welsh Drinks Sector
news

Ten big brands – Welsh drinks sector

Establishing a strong brand is pivotal to business success and protecting that brand is equally important. A brand’s intellectual property rights may include copyrights, trademarks, patents, and more.

Wales is a hotbed of great brands. In the first of a regular series, we look at some of the best brands in the Welsh drinks sector.

aipex logo aipex logo aipex logo